player avatar Adamant

✉ Offers

From
avatarAdamant
168; 139; 0		Steam iconSteam Trades iconDiscord🌎 SA
To
avatarHyuntae
80; 59; 0		Steam iconSteam Trades iconDiscord🌐 ROW:EU
< Proposed
> Accepted
✓ Completed
✓ Completed
Offer Failed Dispute resolved ( about disputes )

avatar Barter.vg volunteered to mediate this dispute.

Adamant claimed I sent item, but received an already used key

Hyuntae claimed what was offered or what I received was not as described

✓ Adamant completed offer with Hyuntae
  • ✓ Hyuntae completed offer with Adamant
  • 🔄 Mediator Barter.vg reset the offer status
  • ✋ Barter.vg volunteered to mediate offer
  • X Hyuntae failed (not as described) offer with Adamant
  • X Adamant failed (key already used) offer with Hyuntae
  • > Hyuntae accepted offer from Adamant
  • < Adamant proposed offer to Hyuntae
  • 🕗 Hyuntae set accepted offer to expire
  • 🕗 Adamant set proposed offer to expire
 
  • avatar I reset the offer and resolved the dispute
  • avatar Thanks Hyuntae and Barter.vg for resolving the issue.
  • Thanks for the clarification
  • avatar I have contacted Steam Support. https://i.imgur.com/hdXNNXQ.png It was indeed an used key (redeemed last summer)
  • ok added
  • avatar It would take some time, but if you want to know what happened with your original Flamebound key, could contact Steam support to discover when the key was activated.
  • Yes, I will trade your key for Flamebound and then provide this new key to Adamant. This should be easier than finding a mutually agreed upon substitute game.
  • avatar Oh... I misunderstood. You gonna use one of my keys to trade it for Flamebound?
  • I should accept and give him an AAA game? I absolutely don't understand why I always need to prove my honesty and never the other party
  • I gave him an un-used key. He pretends it doesn't work. Can he prove it? He wants a replacement, fine. But he wants an AAA game.
  • He can still pick Armored Kitten, Gladiator: Sword of Vengeance, Neighborhorde, or ARAYA. I doubt he would, considering the fact that he absolutely wants King of Fighters and such. This is why he made a report. I don't understand why it should be in my disadvantage.
  • avatar Leaving the dispute unresolved is to your disadvantage and I'd prefer to resolve it rather than wait. Flamebound was in tier 2 Indiegala. Is another tier 2 Indiegala game not a fair substitute? I will use that to trade for another Flamebound.
  • avatar We should respect his decision, and leave the report as it is. He needs to grow. He will come back at me when he would find a reasonable game?
  • They are all Tier 2, while "March" is Tier 1. By the way, it's not our job to find something for himself. He just wants the expensive games written in his wishlist, and nothing else. This is why he made a report.
  • avatar I looked at those examples and they have been in GoGo Bundles. What about games that have been in Indiegala bundles such as Armored Kitten, Gladiator: Sword of Vengeance, Neighborhorde, or ARAYA? Could any of those be substitutes?
  • avatar For examples : Colony On Mars, ROGALIK, Africa Hunting, Santa Run
  • avatar Hyuntae, thank you for replying. I do see that you have lots of tradable. Could you provide 3 examples of tradables that you see as equal replacements for Flamebound?
  • avatar The guy can easily browse my list of games, and come up with some suggestions. Instead of doing that, he just wanted to force me to give him KoF (otherwise report)
  • A trade could fail for some reasons. It can happen, but the way some people jumps onto this opportunity (like no tomorrow) to abuse (and threat with a report) gets me angry
  • Which means a TIER 1 game, and not an AAA game like https://store.steampowered.com/app/222440/THE_KING_OF_FIGHTERS_2002_UNLIMITED_MATCH/
  • Something within the same range than "March of Living" https://steamcdn-a.akamaihd.net/steam/apps/458000/ss_38dcbb6ef79d2666f694d3ede41468cc6fca72d5.jpg?t=1478024238 My list of tradables offers LARGE CHOICE of games
  • avatar Hi, I'll be the mediator for this dispute. I read the screenshot that Hyuntae posted. Hyuntae, which games would you be willing to send as a replacement?
  • avatar I cannot give him a mansion for a bicycle trade. I do not care if my mansion is in whishlist or not. I was willing to give him another bicycle out of my 2 000+ bicycles. Unfriending him now.
  • https://imgur.com/a/DsTmFbS This guy is just lying and forcing things to get more and better. Everything is in the screenshot
Adamant will send 1 of these tradables

⇅ in exchange for

Hyuntae will send 1 of these tradables

You are not signed in to Barter.vg