Barter.vg helps to organize game collections and manage trades. This profile page belongs to a user, but it does not prove anyone's identity or credibility. Be wary of anyone that proposes trades off-site or through private messages. To use this site's dispute process, you must use the on-site offer system to propose or accept trades.

player avatar TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com]

🕵 Pending Review 6 weeks ago

✉ Offers

⚠️ No new offers on Barter.vg after 25 December 2024. Read announcement on Steam Forum

From
avatarTheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com]
474; 326; 1 Dispute		Steam iconSteam Trades iconDiscord🌐 ROW:EU DE
To
avatarGamy
63; 47; 0		Steam iconSteam Trades iconDiscord🌐 ROW:EU NL
< Proposed
> Accepted
✓ Completed
X Failed
Offer Failed Dispute about games or items lost ( about disputes )

TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] claimed ...

Gamy claimed I sent item, but received an invalid key

avatar 🍒 Lilly (🌸◠‿◠) volunteered to mediate this dispute.

✋ 🍒 Lilly (🌸◠‿◠) volunteered to mediate offer ( countered ✉ )
  • X Gamy failed (invalid key) offer with TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com]
  • ✓ TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] completed offer with Gamy
  • > Gamy accepted offer from TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com]
  • < TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] proposed offer to Gamy
  • > TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] countered offer from Gamy with offer
  • 🕗 Gamy set accepted offer to expire
  • 🕗 TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] set proposed offer to expire
  • avatar Of course not. I'm not really happy with the in-game (will never accept that). I will ask to him, hopefully we will figure out.
  • avatar Considering this exchange as complete means that after Gamy activates the code you send, Gamy owns the package (subid) containing the item you used in the trade, which is clearly not the case here. Gamy owns neither the app id, nor the package. On top of that, the trade was not equal in the first place, as this is an item given away for free in large quantities, while Gamy's items are bundled games / DLCs that were never given for free (thus, have some monetary value).
  • The item was indexed from Steam API. You can see that it has a Steam page and an entry on SteamDB. The SteamDB entry even mentions that the package was "Free on demand", although in this case the info hasn't been updated in 9 months. However, what the developer thinks about this item or whether keys exists (existed) for this or not is irrelevant for the trade.
  • avatar ...or maybe the developer consider an in-game key for a Steam product equal to a Steam key as well. :-/
  • ...I just ask because you created that item for something that maybe never has been existed in form of a Steam key. So now I contacted the developer to ask if there was ever a real Steam key existing for that product...
  • avatar @ TheGameMaster: I don't see how this is relevant any more. Barter is not a trading platform any more, and items created on Barter do not transfer to Lestrades or other platforms.
  • avatar @Lilly: would you please add the correct item to barter.vg for the in-game-key of "Puzzle Together - Jigsaw Super Variety Pack" (DLC)?
  • ...and I want to see a proof that he really did buy his stuff as he claimed
  • I still want to know why over a year after the trade this dispute was opened now - why not earlier?!
  • ...seems that he now try to get more profit from me
  • Comment Hidden to Avoid Losing Game: Link detected
  • ...after we had solved the problem he told he would close the dispute and claimed that he had contacted barter.vg support - but this was a lie...
  • avatar Of course not. I'm not really happy with the in-game (will never accept that). I will ask to him, hopefully we will figure out.
  • avatar @Gamy: What would qualify for you as "problem solved"? Are you happy with how the exchange went between you two? If yes, I can close this dispute. If not, then you need to reach out to TheGameMaster again and discuss his willingness to compensate for the 3 keys that you gave him. To make it clear, after the dispute is closed there will probably be no willingness from his part to compensate you.
  • avatar Hi Lily, Yes I told him want closed (if problem solved) and I told i'm not happy with the in-app game (thought it was DLC). It's like micro transaction, don't really like. Mistake can happen. But how made hme good? Have you idea? And have a great weekend.
  • avatar @Gamy: As seen below, TheGameMaster claims that you asked for the dispute to be removed. If this is the case, please confirm that you want it to be removed (without any compensation for your keys) and we will do so ASAP. Even better if you can share some screenshots of the chat.
  • @TheGameMaster your key is not lost, because it was not used. If you don't find an item on Barter, you can always ask us to add it for you.
  • avatar ...and what about a "compensation" for my lost key?!
  • ...and what else should be the correct item on barter.vg for that DLC title?
  • The in-game key is for the steam-version of that game and has an equalent purpose of a steam key which is maybe not existing for that dlc according to steam shop info. :-/
  • ...the "strange situation" is that Gamy says here other things than in chat where he said: "I did ask please remove the dispute (see screenshot above)". And why now over a year later that dispute?!
  • avatar TheGameMaster used (intentionally or not) a wrong Barter item. The key from Alienware is not a Steam key (it's an in-game key and its activation instructions on Alienware clearly state so), thus this item should not have been used. In this case, TheGameMaster should offer a compensation for the 3 items obtained from Gamy. Only after this is done can this dispute be closed.
  • avatar are wasted (few of them are buying) [1 Game and 2 DLC's ]
  • We had talk via Steam. It's strange situation. We had traded indeed but I thought key will used on Steam itself but it's not, it's in-game but I have already had, it's free to obtain on Alienware (long ago), that is why cannot to use again. So my 3 games
  • avatar @Gamy: can this dispute be closed, is everything settled on your side?
  • avatar @Mod ...as we solved via Steam chat: in fact the key was working but the user already had that title so the key seemed invalid - please close this dispute!
  • avatar Comment Hidden to Avoid Losing Game: Link detected
  • avatar the key was correct - show a proof for what you claim!
  • avatar Yes sorry, code is not working for me. But no problem. My games keep it yourself.
  • avatar ...more than a year later suddently a dispute?! :-/
  • Note: Before accepting trade offer please check for other recently accepted offers with same title(s)! Overview
TheGameMaster 2000 [gamehag.com] will send 1 of these tradables

⇅ in exchange for

Gamy will send 3 of these tradables

You are not signed in to Barter.vg